This list uses the Best American Essays series to rank magazines, literary journals, newspapers and other literary nonfiction markets by how often their essays are cited in the anthology.
If you’re writing literary nonfiction and looking for good magazines to submit your essay or other nonfiction, check out these markets.
The ranking covers the last five years (2011 – 2015), and a certain number of points are awarded for an essay appearing in the anthology, and a lesser amount is awarded for the Special Mention in the back of the journal. The Special Mentions are only tallied up for the last two years, though (2014 – 2015) because they run 10 – 15 pages and contain multitudes.
Some differences between this ranking and my Best American Short Stories ranking: the fiction list concentrates on the top journals, while this literary nonfiction one is much more democratic, spreading the wealth of mentions and publications across a far broader span of publications. I’m not sure why that is. It could be because the Best American Essays lists far more special mentions than the Best American Stories, letting them highlight lesser known publications. (If you’re into travel writing, please check out my Best Travel Writing Markets list).
What magazines and journals are punching above their weight class? The big surprises for me were that River Teeth and Southwest Review were ranked so highly, and also Guernica and Normal School made amazing showings.
The Sun and Fourth Genre also placed quite high, considering the company.
The Point, Notre Dame Magazine, Transition, and Prism received a lot of attention, and they’re also ones that are not likely to be on your radar, so pay attention: they’re publishing good stuff, and being recognized for it.
Don’t be too overwhelmed by the numerical place of each of these journals: the number doesn’t necessarily denote quality, it just means that the leaders in the industry (as represented by the guest editors of Best American Essays) have consistently labeled essays from that journal as being top notch. Taste has a large part to play as well. What is fantastic for the journal editor might not be an interesting read for you, and might also not be a good fit for the type of nonfiction you’ve written.
So please take these rankings with a grain of salt, and remember to do your own research and reading to find the right market for your literary nonfiction.
Literary Nonfiction Rankings:
- New Yorker 50
- Granta 29
- Harper’s Magazine 27
- Southwest Review 16
- The Sun 16
- New York Review of Books 16
- Gettysburg Review 16
- Normal School 15
- New York Times Magazine 15
- Paris Review 15
- Oxford American 14
- River Teeth 14
- Tin House 14
- New England Review 13
- The Believer 13
- The American Scholar 13
- Harvard Review 12
- Virginia Quarterly Review 12
- Southern Humanities Review 11
- Guernica 11
- Boulevard 11
- Michigan Quarterly Review 11
- Missouri Review 11
- Kenyon Review 11
- New York Times 10
- Ploughshares 10
- Lapham’s Quarterly 10
- Zyzzyva 10
- Fourth Genre 10
- Threepenny Review 10
- Yale Review 10
- Salmagundi 10
- Atlantic 10
- The Point 10
- Orion 10
- Sewanee Review 10
- Georgia Review 9
- GQ 8
- North American Review 8
- Creative Nonfiction 8
- Crab Orchard Review 8
- New Republic 8
- Hotel Amerika 8
- Notre Dame Magazine 8
- Hobart 8
- McSweeney’s 7
- New York Magazine 7
- Rumpus 7
- Prairie Schooner 7
- Transition 7
- AGNI 7
- Hayden’s Ferry Review 7
- Iowa Review 7
- N+1 7
- Prism 7
- Chattahoochee Review 7
- Washington Post Magazine 6
- New Letters 6
- Massachusetts Review 6
- Narrative 6
- Ecotone 6
- Alaska Quarterly Review 6
- Post Road 6
- Under the Sun 6
- Southern Review 6
- Colorado Review 6
- Grist 5
- Elle 5
- Raritan 5
- Conjunctions 5
- Antioch Review 5
- Commentary 5
- Denver Quarterly 5
- Catamaran 5
- Boston Review 5
- South Loop Review 5 (now called Punctuate)
- Southeast Review 5
- Southern Indiana Review 5
- Little Patuxent Review 4
- Portland Magazine 4
- Salon.com 4
- The Pinch 4
- Chicago Quarterly Review 4
- Humanities 4
- Vanity Fair 4
- A Public Space 4
- Oregon Humanities 4
- 1966: A Journal of Creative Nonfiction 4
- Cutbank 4
- Bellevue Literary Review 4
- New Hibernia Review 4
- Passages North 4
- Upstreet 4
- Five Points 4
- Image 4
- Slice 4
- PMS 4
- Indiana Review 4
- Tampa Review 4
- Literary Review 4
- Brick 4
- New Ohio Review 4
- Ninth Letter 4
- Vice 3
- The Atavist 3
- Zocalo Public Square 3
- Hedgehog 3
- The Pedestrian 3
- Mother Jones 3
- River Styx 3
- Event 3
- Gulf Coast 3
- Florida Review 3
- North Dakota Quarterly 3
- Cleaver Magazine 3
- Buzzfeed 3
- Labletter 3
- TriQuarterly 3
- Witness 3
- Weekly Standard 3
- Columbia 3
- Green Mountains Review 3
- War, Literature, and the Arts 3
- The Baffler 3
- Critical Inquiry 3
- Medium.com 3
- Brevity 3
- Carolina Quarterly 3
- Full Grown People 3
- Solstice 2
- Southern California Review 2
- Briar Cliff Review 2
- December 2
- Superstition Review 2
- Dogwood 2
- Under the Gum Tree 2
- Hudson Review 2
- Consequence 2
- Pleiades 2
- Los Angeles Review 2
- Notre Dame Review 2
- Jabberwock Review 2
- Pembroke Magazine 2
- This Land 2
- Texas Monthly 2
- Black Warrior Review 2
- New Atlantis 2
- Outside 2
- Vogue 2
- Our State 2
- Chautauqua 2
- Sonora Review 2
- Iron Horse Literary Review 2
- SB Nation 2
- Ascent 2
- Slab 2
- Appalachian Heritage 2
- Bellingham Review 2
- Fifth Wednesday 2
- Zone 3 2
- The Nation 2
- Esquire 2
- Gargoyle 2
- Gold Man Review 2
- Midwestern Gothic 2
- Wag’s Revue 2
- South Dakota Review 2
- Harper’s Bazaar 2
- Morning News 2
- Poets & Writers 2
- Ruminate 2
- Water-Stone Review 2
- Hunger Mountain 2
- Fine Art Connoisseur 2
- Daedalus 2
- Blue Lyra Review 1
- Manoa 1
- The Rotarian 1
- American Poetry Review 1
- American Interest 1
- Isthmus 1
- Spiritus 1
- Main Street Rag 1
- New Literary History 1
- Open Letters Monthly 1
- Foreign Affairs 1
- Proud to Be 1
- Journal of Environmental Law and Litigation 1
- American Literary Review 1
- Apple Valley Review 1
- 5280 1
- Washingtonian 1
- Manifest Station 1
- Age, Culture, Humanities 1
- Arts and Letters 1
- Bright Wall, Dark Room 1
- Charlotte 1
- Wake: Great Lakes Thought and Culture 1
- PEN America 1
- Tusculum 1
- The Chronicle 1
- New York Observer 1
- The Forward 1
- As it Ought to Be 1
- Sierra Nevada Review 1
- Cabinet 1
- Aeon 1
- Rathalla Review 1
- National Journal 1
- Smithsonian 1
- One Throne Magazine 1
- Minerva Rising 1
- Prick of the Spindle 1
- Dissent 1
- Mount Hope 1
- Brain, Child 1
- Austin Chronicle 1
- Ars Medica 1
- Roads and Kingdoms 1
- Subtropics 1
- Harvard Divinity Bulletin 1
- American Legion 1
- The Last Word on Nothing 1
- Arcadia 1
- Mayo Clinic Proceedings 1
- Smart Set 1
- Tikkun 1
- Dave’s Travel Corner 1
- Mid-American Review 1
- Bicycling 1
- Desert Exposure 1
- Los Angeles Magazine 1
- Gilbert Magazine 1
- Sport Literate 1
- Masters Review 1
- Trestle Creek Review 1
- Sarasota 1
- The Millions 1
- Hackwriters.com 1
- Her Kind 1
- Aperture 1
- West Branch 1
- Europe Revisited 1
- The Cossack 1
- Third Coast 1
- So to Speak 1
- Memoir 1
- More 1
- Yankee 1
- Beecher’s 1
- Diagram 1
- The Los Angeles Review of Books 1
- Summerset Review 1
- Terrain.org 1
- Bayou 1
- The Magazine 1
- Santa Monica Review 1
- Barely South Review 1
- Stanford 1
- High Desert Journal 1
- Literal Latte 1
- Truth Out 1
- The Morning News 1
- Baltimore Review 1
- Redivider 1
- Vela Magazine 1
- Black Clock 1
- Cincinnati Review 1
- Clockhouse 1
- Lake Effect 1
- Anchorage Press 1
- Rock and Ice 1
- Boston Globe Magazine 1
- Parcel 1
- Feminist Studies 1
- Reason 1
- American Athenaeum 1
- Cimarron Review 1
- Barrelhouse 1
- Free State Review 1
- Jelly Bucket 1
- Wall Street Journal 1
- Delmarva Review 1
- American Journal of Neuroradiology 1
- Open 24 Hours 1
- Apt 1
- Perceptions: A Magazine of the Arts 1
Missing page 236 of 2015 BASS.